'American Horror Story: Coven' Theory Of The Week - Is Queenie Really Dead?

December 18th, 2013 10:03am EST

Gabourey Sidibe as Queenie The wait is long for a new episode of American Horror Story, so in order to quell my (and yours of course) longing for new material, I’ll be checking in periodically with some theories, quandaries and reflections on Coven, so far.
Last week’s brilliant episode, “Head” ended with a shocking and devastating final sequence that found Marie Laveau’s entire tribe decimated by Hank: the witch hunter. Most devastating of all, they killed Queenie! Worst of all, it appears that she is actually dead, not Coven dead, but dead dead. Say it isn’t so. Queenie is a truly interesting character and her journey has been so much fun to watch, from her tough and sassy demeanor which concealed her loneliness, to her unexpected friendship with Delphine. Now, death hasn’t really meant much on the show, since every important character that has “died” has been resurrected, (gotta love those powers of resurgence), or brought back as a ghost, so Queenie’s death isn’t necessarily definite. But there is a sense of finality that plagues this final moment that is inescapable, which makes me believe that time is up for our favorite voodoo doll.
First of all, it’s about that time in the season that the stakes start getting higher and more meaningful. With only four episodes to go in Coven, the narrative is ramping up and nearing its end, which is when all the shit hits the fan. Looking back at previous seasons, this is when things start getting insane and characters start dropping like flies. It is in the tenth episode of Murder House, “Smoldering Children” when it is revealed that (Spoiler Alert!) Violet is dead (the first of the Harmon family to succumb to the house’s evils), even though major clues were dropped beforehand. And episode ten of Asylum, “The Name Game” brought us the death of two major characters, Sister Mary Eunice and Dr. Arden. The confirmation of Queenie’s likely death would fit in to the established narrative structure of the series. Will the tenth episode of Coven continue the show’s death march?
Also, I think there is something to those special blessed, silver bullets Hank used for his assassinations. The writers made a point to highlight that little fact when Cordelia and Fiona have their morning after talk in “The Sacred Taking.” Certainly these bullets have some sort of significant/powerful effect when used against witches. Silver bullets are a science fiction/fantasy cliché by now, but the implications are clear. So, even though Queenie was employing her “voodoo doll” power when she shot herself (thus killing Hank) it didn’t prevent the silver bullet’s effect on her body. Furthermore, an injury so violent and severe could be too grave for her magic to overcome. We have seen her inflict pain upon other people with her power, but she has never gone so far as to actually kill them. Maybe her power is limited in that way.
To be honest, it’s about time that people start dying on this show, and though I’m sorry if Queenie is the first to go, it is a necessary evil. Again, this season’s stakes have been ridiculously low; there has been no sense of danger or tension whatsoever, that is, until last week’s developments. Ultimately, Queenie’s death would be a more impactful and dramatic way for the story to go (a major loss for the characters as well as the viewers) than just having her revived by Misty Day and have everything back to kind of normal the next day.
Do you think Queenie’s really gone?

Related: American Horror Story, Gabourey Sidibe, Horror, Television, Starpulse Exclusives, Television, Previews, FX

Photo Credits: FX

Previous: 'Sex Tape' May Have Bombed Due To Its Title

Next: 'Covert Affairs' Star Piper Perabo Marries Director Stephen Kay

More on American Horror Story